Shut out! But its not all bad.
Posted on 17. Dec, 2009 by Philip Ireland in Australia

Candles at the 'Vigil for Survival' held at the new NGO space
I have now been officially shut out of the negotiations.
To cut a long story short, the UNFCCC allowed too many registrations for this event (around 3 times the venue capacity). Over the past few days they have been reducing the number of people allowed in the centre… as you may have guessed, it is the NGOs (this includes, universities, environmental groups, development agencies, youth constituencies, unions etc.) that have been shut out. Of the over 15000 who were registered, only 7000 were allowed in on Tuesday and Wednesday. I was lucky to be amongst this group.
But then, the UNFCCC took things a few steps too far and has only allowed 300 NGO people in the building for the final 2 days. Yes, that’s right, 300 people. At last count, I think Australia had 3 NGO representatives on the inside (which is more than our quota).
My perspective on this is that some cuts were practically necessary, however, 300 is quite frankly a scandal. There are around 5000 media here who have received very little restriction and around 10,000 government representatives (some countries have over 500 registered attendees).
Whilst, I do not consider my role in the process essential, I know many people from other organisations who provide critical support to developing countries. Most of these people have been blocked out.
The UNFCCC and the Danish Government have made a grave error
Civil society has been sidelined.
The integrity of this process has been degraded.
Today….
The events of today have been mixed. I am growing tired of the speeches by heads of state which take 5-15 minutes each and have been going for the past 24 hours. There are over 100 heads of state here…. You do the maths. There are glimpses of inspiration and courage, however, for the large part this is an exercise in repeating known positions.
We have, however, been hearing in the past few hours though that there has been some positive movement. Some of the key progressions are:
-New drafting groups have formed with Ministers
-The United States has signalled its support for a 100bn US$ per annum fund for mitigation and adaptation in the developing world by 2020
-Prime Minister Kevin Rudd publically supported the possibility of the Kyoto Protocol continuing
In other news, Australia has been awarded its first ‘Fossil of the day’ award from Climate Action Network, an award for countries who are perceived to be impeding the negotiations. This was awarded as a result of revelations that Australia has been pressuring Pacific Islands States to lower their demands.
Stay tuned to the adopt a negotiator website for all the updates over the next 24 hours. And, don’t believe everything you read in the Australian media. I have been following it on line and have found that often it is not reflecting what is actually going on here (I am sure this comes as no surprise!).
What will happen is still anyone’s guess. Heads of states have the power to make these large decisions very quickly.
And… I would like to thank all of you who have sent messages of support over the past day. You will be happy to know that I did get a solid 7 hours sleep and am as ready as I will ever be for tomorrow (if your reading this in Australia that’s your today)
Tracking for you, for one final day,
Phil.
Ps. Take action on our sister site A Climate for Change!
The Adopter - Phillip Ireland
Phil grew up in Newcastle on the beautiful east coast of Australia. He's deeply concerned about the impacts of climate change on poor communities around the globe, which has shaped a passion for activism around these issues. Phil is a Ph.D. candidate at Macquarie University in Australia... read more»







It’s sad you are locked out phil, and the sidelining of society is worse. It’s great to finally hear Rudd’s position on the KP. We are still watching carefully!
In the midst of that sinking sense of an inability for change, I am heartened to know that you’re in there Phil (even if it is in the warehouse!). It sounds mad, confused and depressing -but I am living in hope. Keep at it for the final run mate.
Good on you, Phil. Very useful insights. Sorry you have (involuntarily) left the building. With all the knowledge and passion in Copenhagen – & globally with you in spirit, the negotiators and the heads of government must know that we expect a real deal.
Hey Phil, your new sister-in-law put me onto your blog so I will follow with interest. Hope to see you in Nepal on your way back!