David Tong

12 November, 2013

And they laughed.

_MG_2158

When a journalist from the New Zealand Herald asked me why I was going to Warsaw, I said it was because I had only ever been ashamed to be a New Zealander once. It was when I was in Durban and I faced the withering scorn of a small island negotiator saying New Zealand was pushing Kyoto Protocol negotiations down to the lowest level of ambition. I believe we have a duty to our Pacific neighbours, and so that cut deep.

Now make that twice - and not because of anything New Zealand’s negotiators did or anything that happened here.

I’m ashamed of my government because they laughed when Russel Norman of the Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand linked Typhoon Haiyan to climate change. They laughed. They mocked him. They yelled “shame”. Let me say that again: when Yeb Saño was quoted in the New Zealand Parliament, people laughed.

The worst typhoon ever recorded hit last weekend. It killed over 10,000 people. 478,000 people have been displaced. Real, human, people, with families and children and lives and loves. Philippine lead negotiator Yeb Saño is one such real person, and he pledged to fast until a deal was done for all our futures. And my elected leaders laughed. No one here in Warsaw is laughing. In fact, 30 or more people are joining Yeb in his fast.

487426_246780365479131_44430400_nYou might have seen that one of the other Adopt a Negotiator Fellows this year is Carlie Labaria. She is here with us in Warsaw. But she is from the Philippines. She is another of those real people hit by Haiyan, and she is kind, funny, and very smart. It’s a privilege to work with her. When she spoke yesterday on behalf of youth to the United Nations, people didn’t laugh. When she pled for dignity, people didn’t laugh.

Members of my government accused an opposition Member of Parliament of being “political” for linking climate change to Haiyan. But the link is clear. While it is impossible to conclusively say that climate change caused a single weather event, we can be confident that climate change makes typhoons and “hellstorms” more likely. As my fellow Trackers have stressed already, climate change fuelled Haiyan. Sea surface temperatures around the Philippines were as much as two degrees above normal. This is not the old normal. It is the new abnormal.

That’s the science. That’s not up for debate here in Warsaw. And that is why it is not political to stand with the Philippines, but an act of basic human respect.

UPDATED:

I salute you Russel Norman. My deepest appreciation for your heartwarming gesture. I wish you the best. - Yeb Saño

climateclimate changecop19haiyanNew ZealandparliamentUNFCCCyebYeb Sano

About The Author

David Tong

David is an experienced New Zealand lawyer, now working towards his Masters of Laws. He is one of two founding co-chairs of the Aotearoa New Zealand Human Rights Lawyers Association and chairs P3 Foundation, New Zealand’s youth movement against extreme poverty. He was also a New Zealand Youth Delegate to the 2011 Durban talks.

*Check your email inbox to confirm subscription.
  • Pujarini Sen

    Really moved by this David. Looking fwd to more from you. And Carlie :)

  • http://thesolution.org.nz/ David Tong

    Thanks Pujarini!

  • Nikki Hodgson

    Well said.

  • http://avikroyblogs.wordpress.com/ Avik Roy

    Hats off to you David for this awe-inspiring piece. You hit it where it ought to be hit. Looking forward to read more such critique from you.

  • Anna Zhang

    What a powerful story.
    Choked a little when I read it.
    What would you recommend people (like me) do - the ones that aren’t at the talks - how can we help???

  • http://thesolution.org.nz/ David Tong

    Thanks Anna! You’re in Australia, so I’d suggest you connect with the Australian Youth Climate Coalition: http://aycc.org.au/

    Otherwise, write your own thoughts, share things online, and spread the word. If you want, fast in solidarity (full disclosure - I’m not, because COP is hard enough and I’m here to cover it and make sure the story’s told). This isn’t about the people here. This is about building a mass global movement for climate justice.

  • @jadz

    I know a few New Zealanders and they are all nice. So I didn’t expect such a disrespectful behavior during a deliberation, and from parliamentarians at that. Shame!

  • Call Sign 30

    There was no disrespect shown to the beautiful people of the Philippines only disrespect to a shamefull politician who mis-used an opportunity to offer the support of his political party “the Greens” to the people of the Philippines but instead hysterically blamed the west for global warming and blamed the typhoon on global warming which is a massive conclusion to make without conclusive science to prove it. Yes we are still laughing at Norman Russell while crying for the people of the Philippines

  • dontblamenz

    Well I heard people talking loudly, but laughing, come on!! . NZ is such a country who preserve their natural resources so that the flora and fauna will not be destroyed. This is a country with pristine untouched beauty, and people really care about their environment, and I know this cause I live here. The country is so conscious and very careful of the well being of its people and even the tiniest of creatures that flourish here.

  • Enna

    Great piece - thank you for writing it. I watched the speeches in Parliament yesterday as I normally watch QT then, and I was ashamed and horrified by the way the Govt benches behaved.

  • Anonymous

    A truly shameful reaction from many in the National Party, the lack of respect shown to Dr Norman was really a lack of respect to the people of the Philippines in their sorrow and their anger. It was a nauseating show of hypocrisy from these MPs’ - their response to a heartfelt plea from a suffering nation as relayed by Dr Norman was sanctimonious and offensively dismissive - we’ll take a few minutes out of our busy important lives to relay our deepest sympathy with the dead and dispossessed in the Philippines, but when we’ve done that, we’ll best get back to the really important things like drilling for more oil, digging up more coal and building more motorways.

    But then when one of the Australians who had lost his very home in the recent unprecedentedly early bush fires in Australia, following the hottest ever year recorded in that country, was heard to say on TV that this was nothing to do with climate change, then you know Dr Norman’s speech and Yeb Saño’s plea will likely fall on ground as barren as the searing Australian desert, and our descendants will indeed suffer the consequences of our greed and stupidity.

  • http://thesolution.org.nz/ David Tong

    I’m a New Zealander too, sad to be missing our summer for my work in Warsaw and Geneva. And I don’t believe we do a good job preserving our natural resources. Check out the first post I ever wrote here, back in 2011: http://adoptanegotiator.org/2011/12/01/clean-and-green-aotearoa-new-zealand/

    A study last year found that over half the test sites in our rivers weren’t safe for swimming. We are ripping up the Denniston Plateau, despite its unique ecosystem.

    I wish we were, but we aren’t as good as the hype.

  • http://thesolution.org.nz/ David Tong

    You know he was quoting the Philippine lead climate negotiator who is from the worst hit area, right? Yeb’s brother is still counting corpses, so I think he’s a bit more qualified to decide what his people want.

    If you were crying for the people of the Philippines, you wouldn’t laugh at their representative’s heartfelt words.

    On the science - I’ve linked to my sources. Love you see yours.

  • Rob Painting

    “I’m ashamed of my government because they laughed when Russel Norman of the Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand linked Typhoon Haiyan to climate change. They laughed.”

    Sadly, scientific illiteracy is not a barrier to political office. I’m sure these same pollies don’t scoff at science that presents no challenge their particular brand of ideology.

    Hopefully we can avoid another major drought in New Zealand this summer, but the current state of the Pacific Ocean doesn’t look too promising. And Australia look like they could be in for another major heat wave soon too.

    I expect that the average Joe or Jane public will soon forget about this tragedy, but many extreme weather events are going to occur with greater frequency and intensity, so it won’t be long until the next climate-related disaster occurs.

  • Rob Painting

    I don’t know where you are living, but the New Zealand I have grown up in is nothing like you describe.

  • Anonymous

    Thanks for this report David. It is sad when so many intelligent people refuse to acknowledge the scientific connections between climate change and extreme weather events. It is even worse when they mock such a solemn contribution to parliamentary debate with loud chatter and even laughter. They have no respect for the millions of people affected in the Philippines by Haiyan, the strongest typhoon on record to make landfall. And it came just a year after another category 5 storm, Bopha caused significant death and destruction. And thank you Russel Norman, and for all those at the COP in Warsaw acting with humanity and solidarity.

  • Lily Pedro

    Typical deny-ers. The whimsical notion of the national party and the speaker, that the lives and natural environments of the Philippines people is not political (sigh). It is euro/american-centric politics again assuming a magical power to define: in this case, of when a message of grief is comfortable for them to sit through, and when the truth of the Philippines actual ‘words’ becomes so uncomfortable, it evokes sharp reaction from the dehumaniser. (side bar, call sign 30:- Simon Bridges, is that really you?…I digress). It matters not that the silencing of reality is a complete disgrace. They are always going to do it, its nothing new.
    What does matter is that Dr. Russel Norman has enough love and respect in his heart to carry on. Deny-er’s struggle to understand that concept. They react with the distraction of justification politics instead. But Dr. Norman knows it, that’s why he will continue to stand and speak for those who suffer greatly, for those who have lost, and very importantly, for those who continue to fight.
    Ka aroha nui ki te tangata o te whenua Philippines.
    And to Dr. Russel Norman, rock on!

  • Pingback: ccn2785xdnwdc5bwedsj4wsndb()

  • Pingback: xcn5bsn5bvtb7sdn5cnvbttecc()