PENGON/Anti-Apartheid Wall Campaign Photo

A lone olive tree along the Israel - Palestine border

As the un climate negotiations in Cancun head towards their close what we have always known, always tried to hide from, and yet never quite managed, is becoming more and more clear.

These negotiations are not about policy, or process. They are about politics.

And yet when we leave these halls, when we return to the real world, when we confront the face of climate change that hides behind the endless acronyms, we see clearly that climate change is not about process, or policy. And it’s definitely not about politics.

It is about people.

It’s about the people now unable to farm their land, it’s about the people walking further and further each day for water, it’s about the people whose homes are slowly disappearing into the sea.

When countries come to the un they are representing their people, they vote on behalf of their people. In this way supposedly every person on the planet is represented here. But what happens if your country isn’t a country, what happens if your land is contested, what happens if politics once more get in the way.

Climate change considers no geographical or political borders, yet when we as humans impose them, then invariably contest them, it is the people who loose out.

Palestine pretty much embodies the word politics, an occupied land with contested borders. Yet Palestine is also on the front line of climate change, an arid land with scarce water resources. If we put the politics aside how are the people of Palestine, the people facing the harshest of conditions, the hardest of lives, how are they able to engage, to have their voice heard in the un climate talks?

Officially Palestine is an observer country at the unfccc. This means they are allowed to take part in all meetings and can speak on the floor, but at the end of the day they cannot vote. In practice this doesn’t always run as smoothly. They have a different colour badge to parties (an olive green vs the party pink) and they have an official letter from the secretariat confirming their ability to attend closed meetings. However when confronted with a security guard with one set of instructions, the different colour is all it takes to be locked out of meetings. Even just being here to participate is more difficult for them. The unfccc funds 2 delegates from every country, not so for observer parties, and they are often left scrabbling for funds at the last minute.

But they are here and they are participating. They are here because back at home it is their land and their families who are bearing the brunt of the onset of climate change. One negotiator I spoke to told me of his family, of his farm. For 30 years they have planted the land, they have lived off what they grow. Now water is scarce, there is not enough of it to irrigate, what they have is too precious to put on the crops. Now they can no longer plant, they can no longer grow. And it is not just his land, in the margins between the West Bank and the desert, in land where herders have lived for thousands of years, there is no longer enough water to grow the fodder to sustain the herds. Land is becoming desert, and as the land goes so does the livelihoods of those who rely on it.

As water becomes scarcer and irrigation a pipe dream all the farmers can do is rely on rain fed agriculture. But the last 7 years have been 7 consecutive dry years. Even the olive trees are dying.

Climate change is a reality in Palestine, the people there are already facing it head on. There is no reversing what has happened, all they can do is live with the consequences. They must now adapt.

Of course adaptation is a huge part of the unfccc, back here in Cancun I am sat with the draft text in front of me, text that should one day lead to developed countries facing up to their historic responsibility and providing funds for developing countries.

But when your country is not a country, when you have no say and are forced to observe, when your people are not represented, then you also don’t have the right to this money.

As an observer not a party to the unfccc process, the people of Palestine have no access to the billions of dollars of funding that will one day soon hopefully start to flow. No access to funds that could mean the difference between life and death. For Palestine this is not a political issue, it is not geographical, it is not even environmental. For Palestine this is a humanitarian issue, another humanitarian issue on top of the many they are already struggling with. As their negotiator said “We are not less than other countries and we are not more, we are equal.” Adaptation funding is not about politics, it is about people. Regardless of politics, the people of Palestine deserve access to funds that could save their life. Palestine is prepared, they have a national adaptation strategy, but without funds they can do nothing. The farmland will continue to be swallowed by the desert, the people will begin to starve.

“Geographically we are part of this world, our people need to be counted, that’s all we want here.”

Regardless of politics, regardless of country status, regardless of the colour of their negotiators badge here at the unfccc, the people of Palestine, the people who have done little or nothing to contribute to climate change, deserve access to funds, access to the means to sustain their way of life.

For an olive green badge are we going to let the olive trees die.

This is not about politics, this is about people.

Tagged with:
 
  • Joshua Wiese

    Really moving post Anna. Thanks for letting us know a bit about their situation. Never occurred to me…

  • Wael Hmaidan

    Thanks Anna for this article on a country from our region. We have been heavily feeling climate change impacts this past month.

  • http://twitter.com/Mau_IvanX Ivan

    Wow I’m surprised. I didn’t know this. But a really good and emotive post.

  • Nedal Katbeh

    Many Thanks Anna,
    Looking for wider possible distribution. Palestinians are punished twicw, by occupation and by not being able to access funds. We are looking for Environmental Justice. The impact of Climate Change on our most vulnrable people are unavoidable and untolerable. Social vulnerability caused by climate change is highly exacerbated by the impact of occupation which largely hindr the cobing ability of local peole by denying them from controling and accessing t

  • Aman

    Regards and highly appreciated for this article Anna.It is deep humutirainian issue. Climate change effects in our palestineis highly esrious daily life topic,at same time it is caused and effected by occupation polysis.how our people will be without access for their life,lands,resourses,and also their futur.how could be adapting without their self control.again thank you

  • Ayman Thaher

    Regards and highly appreciated for this article Anna.It is deep humutirainian issue. Climate change effects in our palestineis highly esrious daily life topic,at same time it is caused and effected by occupation polysis.how our people will be without access for their life,lands,resourses,and also their futur.how could be adapting without their self control.again thank you

  • Jameel Mtour

    Tha nks alot Anna ,really , you articulate and reflect the story of Palestine in agood expressions .

    We are ready to suply you with more and more stories of suffering in Palestine .

    Article is highly appreciated . Best Regards . Jameel Mtour , Deputy Chairman of Enviroment Quality Authority , Ramallah , Palestine

  • Dr Yousef Abu-Safieh

    ANNA you are great for this deep heartedly article which realy reflects part of the agonies of the Palestinian people. I was so sad that I could not attend the global gathering in Cancun because I got stuck in Gaza under home arrest. When I read your article I sighed and felt relaxed because still there is some one who cares for the endless Palestinian tragedy of negation of their right to dream for a better future for their children not only by the occupier but also by the internationl community. Are we, the Palestinians, destined to face the brutality of the occupation and that of the climate change adverse impacts because our identity have been stolen some six decades ago ? Thanks and gratitude Anna. Minister, Dr. Yousef Abu-Safieh, Chiarman of Environment Quality Authority, Occupied Gaza, free Palestine

  • Imad khatib

    It reflects the deep strong roots of the Olive trees against a strange extraneous wall

  • Ayman Thaher

    Height is greater heights in Western States
    Israel would double the quantity of gaseous emissions until 2030

    J. k./on prospects for the environment and development: a recent report prepared by the recently unveiled a “McKenzie” international consulting, for Israeli environment authority, that is, until 2030, that Israel has doubled the quantity of their greenhouse gases (i.e. up to 100%). and estimated quantity of greenhouse gases will, after 21 years, to 142 million tonnes, compared with 71 million tonnes currently. height is greater than the expected rises in Western countries; in Germany, for example, is projected to increase the quantity of gases in the same period increased by 14%, and in the United States by 24%.
    Authors believe that possible, until 2030, reduce some 64% (two thirds) of the height, by technical means, such as reduced use of lighting, and increased use of public transport and cycling, and cooling temperatures and reduced meat consumption. The report also refers to the possibility of producing 25% of electricity by renewable energy. In total, can reduce the expected rise in greenhouse gases to 36%.
    Unlike other Western countries, Israel did not have sufficient means of reducing emissions such as carbon sequestration and storage (CCS), hydropower production, as well as the widespread use of bioenergy.
    In turn, attacked some Israeli authority environment environmental organizations, because a recent emission cap to shrink below the targets by developed countries. Accused as environment authority behave as if the Earth problem involving others, therefore the solution is not her hand. They said that the report ignores the indirect benefits that can lead to additional benefits for the economy and society, together with GHG mitigation. We develop plans to promote public transport, for example, additional costs for road construction, traffic congestion will be reduced, as well as reducing harm health.
    While Israel is heading towards increased emissions by 36%, many States now deliberately, to reduce their emissions of greenhouse gases, and some will, by 2020, reduced about 40%.
    Some climate experts estimated that if Israel on renewable energy by 25%, the expected profit of the Israeli economy, 2030, reach 12.5 billion shekels, as well as create new jobs.
    Electricity production sector is the first official Israel most emissions; it produces more than half the emissions, and specifically about 55% of total emissions. And then comes the communications sector which produces approximately 18% of emissions. Waste sector produces approximately 9% of total emissions.
    The report says that Israel can reduce greenhouse gas emissions through actions requires each financial investment, while others do not require any investment. Located in first class infrastructure for the production of electricity by solar energy, investment in infrastructure for public transport and recycling. Israeli Environment Authority announced that it sought to increase the exploitation of solar energy to produce electricity, as the most important way to reduce emissions. Authority says that its goal is to be a renewable energy production in the quarter of Israel, that renewables are currently only 1% of total electricity production in Israel.
    According to the same report, include procedures falling within the second category which do not require a financial investment, increase energy efficiency, such as exploitation of waste of electricity production, and improve residential green building specifications, and change the proportions of fuels in the energy market. These procedures may lead to reduction in CO2 by 45 million tonnes, a reduction of approximately savings resulting from investment in renewable energy.
    The report also indicates that change the Israelis to behaviour can lead to a reduction of greenhouse gases by 7 million tons. Among the changes focus report: rationalize and reduce energy and water consumption in homes, reduce consumption of beef, raise the temperature of air conditioners and greater use of bicycles instead of cars.

  • Ayman thaher

    Palestinian world for “together”: we have succeeded in thwarting the demographic battle Zionism
    الثلاثاء, 14 ديسمبر 2010 12:12 | author fateh | | |
    Palestinian world for “together”: we have succeeded in thwarting the demographic battle Zionism

    Our Palestine - Jerusalem - together - under the title “Palestinian demography foiled plan 2000-2020″ singled d. Ibrahim technical in this article are important:

    Of Statistics Central Bureau of Statistics Israel, which operates under the supervision of the Prime Minister of Israel, we read that the demography of Palestinian population in Jerusalem, the bacillus to give planners the Jerusalem Municipality, the Ministry of Interior and Justice, Israel reduced the number of the Arab population to the proportion of 20-15% of the population of the holy city.

    Plan 2000-2020 by the Israeli Central Bureau of Statistics when the values of the agenda of the plan reached through statistical proportion of the population that currently has 35% Palestinians, Jews and others, 65% and if it stays like this in 2020 will account for 40% of the Palestinians and the meaning of the concept of Greater Jerusalem.

    Recommendations of the 2020 Plan must work to abolish the demographic growth of the Palestinian population of this, the Israeli municipality of Jerusalem, the confiscation of land is open, and also convert green areas to areas of the building, promising the Palestinians that they will give them licenses buildings in a part of the green areas, especially in the village of Issawiya Village phase, and this was the adoption of the legal text of occupying Power that these lands have no names in the books of land records mandatory.

    Planning Group in the municipality of Jerusalem and the Israeli community planning not to recommend the granting of licenses for the Palestinians, which will lead to a cessation of Palestinian population growth in Jerusalem until 2030.

    Recommendation demographers

    Israel should turn green areas in Jerusalem and the villages to the areas of building settlements, thus forcing the Palestinians to leave the West Bank, and this will be the accomplishment of a demographic that would deprive Israel of the Palestinians to have their political identity in Jerusalem

    Arrived in Maale Adumim with Jerusalem:
    The decision of the Planning Commission to allow the Supreme mayor of Maale Adumim, the establishment of South and North buildings Issawiya shoulders and the stage, and completion of the main street and tunnels that have been implemented which will make Maale Adumim, the eastern gate of the city of Jerusalem.

    The master plan developed thirtieth avoid failure if developed construction work in each of the settlement of Ramot, Gilo and Homa and Pisgat Zeev, Chairman of the Planning Commission considered the revised plan project fundamental, legal and adoption within Salahiap Chairman of the Organizing Committee High, where they are vested in making the adjustments and changes to the plan without consultation or negotiation as the project is a local recipe, or cycle to the team and the Ministry of Interior and the municipality considered the plan to 1 / 30 was necessary in order to plan demographics that correspond to several areas across the geopolitical reality that the city of Greater Jerusalem the eternal capital of the State of Israel.

    That the policy of Israeli governments have relied on demography, by the holy city was divided for a period of nineteen years between the years 1948-1967, the Israeli leadership feared the day that calls for Palestinian residents of Jerusalem who have obtained Israeli identity after 1967, would demand the acquisition of nationality Palestinian as well as compensation for the damage wrought by their occupation, prompting Ben-Gurion, first Prime Minister of Israel after the 1967 war, saying:
    “We must issue a warrant contains four content so as not to get to the decay”:

    • You must bring Jews into East Jerusalem at any cost.
    • We must provide housing facilities to ten thousands of Jews from time to time.
    • Jews will accept the settlement in East Jerusalem, even if there were terrorist acts.
    • We can not wait for consultations or negotiations with our neighbors.
    • What is essential and necessary to be Jewish settlement in Jerusalem.

    About 70,000 acres have been annexed to Jerusalem after the 1967 war, including coverage of trends in the four and this in order to expand the municipal boundaries of Jerusalem, the main consideration should the maker of the Israeli decision was taken, that oversees and monitors all what is happening on the land of Jerusalem, to be Palestinian citizens as a minimum .

    In 1972, The Center for Statistics published for the Israeli population in Jerusalem was the Jews 73.5 25.5 Palestinians, and over the years, the Israeli ministerial group working on a file of Jerusalem, which is the follow-up actions in Jerusalem and the preparation of plans and then submit them to the Israeli decision-maker.

    Decision-maker Israeli describe the master plan for the year 1995, which ratified in 2007 substance beyond reason and understanding regarding the demography, a lack of understanding that there must be a majority Jewish city of Jerusalem, because the rate of population increase Palestinians over the Jews, compared to figures issued by the Central Bureau of Statistics , in the suburbs, where the proportion of Jews over Palestinians in the suburbs, but the ratio is equal to the Palestinians give birth at 1-3 to in favor of the Palestinians.

    The 2000 plan led to a contraction in the number of Jewish population by studying the results reached by demographers in the plan 2020, and found it would be a disaster for the government and planners, where will be the proportion of Jews 60% and the Palestinians 40%, and that is quick to modify the plan under the name 30 / 1, where deliberately plan to adopt measures equivalent to what has in the plan from the results of 2020, where the number of the city’s population of about 950,000 people, 570,000 Jews and 380,000 Palestinians, and the plan led to the increase in Palestinian population three times that of the Jews.

    Plan 2000-2020 Foundation established its mission to build the apartheid wall, as recommended by Ben-Gurion, after the 1967 war, Israelis and the deployment of a bad situation where what was sought by the Jerusalem municipality from denying about 50-90 thousand Palestinians were living outside Jerusalem, but returned to the city and this is what led to the failure of the 2020 Plan.

    The decision taken by the Chairman of the Planning Commission, which provides for annexation of 1800 dunums to Plan 2020 in order to give Palestinians permits buildings in the Arab neighborhoods, was soon in custody and to begin preparing a plan of 30 / 1 now Center of Statistics published figures for the Palestinian population in Jerusalem, where it reached 270,000 Palestinians in East Jerusalem, and this figure will rise to become a 380 000 2020, this should extend the forecast period, which provides for the granting of benefits to build housing units for the Palestinians instead be extended to 2020 2030.

    In September of 2009, a journalist Ictool’ve chosen, which was published in the newspaper Yediot Aharonot, an investigation into a reserve housing and residential units that will build for the Jews in 2010-2011, and found that the reserve housing for 2020 will be 23,200 housing units, this entitlement considered the structure of a scientific fact that a Building construction is not a densely populated, it is not enough to fulfill the needs of the Jewish population growth in Jerusalem until 2020.

    It is important to stop the bleeding constraints of Jewish immigration to Jerusalem
    Jewish demographic strength is to be a majority Jewish population in Jerusalem, this should provide financial incentives with the government program calls for socio-economic attraction for housing in Jerusalem.

    The first step requires the issuance of a government guarantee includes the creation and innovation display provides for the presentation of land for an intensive residential units with a plan to build tens of thousands of housing units, for fear of access to change negative impact on the demography which requires the existence of a Jewish majority in Jerusalem.

    The demands of Palestinian non-contact between East Jerusalem and the settlement blocs and the State of Israel want them to be outside the city: green areas, have been prepared outline design has to be converted to the areas of building, Israeli prosecutors said that this was to give the Palestinians, singled out buildings in all those areas Loki rescind this resolution, the text of Plan 2030 calls for the division of green areas and a barrier hindering Palestinian population growth in the city of Jerusalem, and this is not only the preparation of legal study through which to issue a judicial decision determines the influence of the city, and links between areas of the Palestinian presence in Jerusalem with the outer regions.

    Filstinon consider all of the West Bank and East Jerusalem, occupied land, land Davlathemen must both Israel and the United Nations to recognize this, and this is not civil, but that benefit a political, diplomatic, which corresponds to the international resolutions that recognize that all of Jerusalem and the West Bank and Gaza Strip and the geographical unit, Also, the Palestinians oppose the building and the establishment of the apartheid wall, which would deny them the right to statehood and Jerusalem as its capital.

    What are the reasons that made the political decision to put a red line to prevent any registered land in East Jerusalem?
    Israeli government bacillus and above international law does not assume any responsibility meaningful to clarify its position in front of the works in international law and who recognize that Jerusalem is occupied territory and that Israel canceled the concept of the Green Line, which will not be dependent properties confiscated by the owners, this has provided a number of Palestinian petitions to the Court of Justice to issue a decision to register their land, but Israel has set up a circle in the Israeli Justice Ministry, which received loud and clear that he had been suspended in this resolution, which was issued by a diplomatic spokesman on behalf of the Ministry of Justice.

    It notes that indicated the lack of success of the Plan 2000-2020 mostly relates to not having the infrastructure in East Jerusalem, in the absence of no record Tabou in the old town determines the properties of buildings, and that the Government of Israel will be issued a judicial decision and to be approved by the Knesset to become law, requires an inventory of registered buildings holders who are immigrants and Israeli law, absent consideration of their property and belongs to the state for this must be recorded in the Israeli Justice Ministry.

  • Paulina Monforte

    Anna, I’m going to use this info for my thesis and I’m so happy I get to quote you. You’re an amazing writer, I can’t wait to organise things together.

  • Guest

    hy is it only an observer? UN membership is not required (Niue and Cook Islands are) and there are no UNFCCC rules governing membership (no 2/3rd or concensus vote count). I’ve seen many statements, including the Palestinian delegation’s statement last December, saying membership has been denied, but I have not found a record of how/why?

More in United Kingdom (31 of 130 articles)